Cori (00:00):
Welcome to the Redefining Strength Podcast, everything you need to succeed on your health and fitness journey, even the stuff you don’t want to hear. We’re here to talk about silencing that inner critic. I’m super excited to be joined by Alison. I know it can be hard sometimes to silence those doubts, to stop those negative thoughts, but it’s so key that we do learn how to control that mindset if we want to move forward. So Alison, thank you so much for joining me. Let’s jump into talking about why that inner critic is even there.
Allison (00:33):
Hey, yes. So we come by it naturally, which I think can be a nice relief that our brains are kind of wired for this. They’re wired to keep us safe. So if we think back to cave people times, we had to be part of a group in order to stay alive, obviously. I mean, hopefully not worrying about bears chasing us anymore, but we still have that desire to be part of a group. And in modern life though that inner critic turns into this super mean girl, harsh self-judgment instead of helpful self-correction and lucky us as women, we tend to have this even more so because of all of those societal pressures that we face with being able to do it all. And you see those Pinterest perfect parties and all of that reinforcement that we’re just not doing enough.
Cori (01:29):
I am definitely more along the lines of the Pinterest fail images you see, especially if it’s anything party related. But I do think it’s really oddly comforting to know that we have this negativity bias, this judgment bias, and it’s therefore both a positive reason and it can really help us reflect. But there can be that negative side to it because I think the more we recognize something is natural, the more we don’t beat ourselves up for it, but the more we also see the opportunity in learning to use it to our advantage even.
Allison (01:59):
Yes, and that’s exactly the difference between self-compassion and self-criticism is acknowledging that we’re all part of this struggle and we can learn from those moments of setback. We can find ways to find the positive that 1% better and really be able to get out of that failure mindset. Because when we’re criticizing ourselves over and over again, it can be really easy to believe that what’s the point of trying? I’m just a failure. I might as well not even do this. You hear that often enough. What do you think your motivation to actually change is going to be? So by not utilizing this shame as a way to just get stuck, but rather utilizing it as a way to focus on what were some of the circumstances around this failure that led me to behave this way. So for example, I like to think about driving in, you have a really long hard day at work and you’re just ready to get home.
(03:10):
You’ve got a plan. You’re going to get your workout in, make dinner for the family, but you’ve had a super long day and everything just seemed to go wrong. You’re driving home and there’s an awful traffic jam. Your response after having all of that experience is probably going to be much different than if you had a really awesome day at work. And you can look at that traffic jam as like, oh, this is annoying, but whatever, I’ll deal with it. Put on some music rock out versus this always happens to me now. I’m not going to be able to get my workout in. So those circumstances can really be the difference maker in how we respond. And the more we’re aware of, Hey, we’re not a failure. We’re not intrinsically bad because we didn’t do the thing we said we were going to do. There’s a bigger picture there. And so then we can identify, okay, what were the challenges? How can I make just one tiny change now maybe I don’t have time to get my full workout in. Can I do a dance party with my kiddos while we’re making dinner or take the dog for a walk?
Cori (04:16):
We can really shift our perspective, which is everything because how we perceive that event, it shapes how we move forward from it. And a lot of the things that happen prior do shape our perspective of it, but the more we recognize the cycle that we can be in and the impact each of these components can have, the more we can step back and even realize when we’re critiquing ourselves in justifying the critique as, oh, well I’m learning from this. It’s good to be hard on myself to make sure that I’m not just letting things slide and I’m moving forward. But we have to realize there’s a dark side to everything and what can be a strength can also be a weakness. So stepping back to assess these different things and even realizing where your perception of the event is coming from can be so important because that’s what leads to, as you said, finding the 1% that can really make a difference.
Allison (05:05):
Exactly. And so there’s a few ways that we can actually start to recognize how we can make those changes. Because if we’re just aware of it, okay, cool, but we have to move beyond that awareness. And so the first thing is that instead of just continuing to be ourself up for all of these mistakes, think about how you would speak to a friend. I like to think that most of us speak nicely to our friends, otherwise we probably don’t have a whole lot of friends. So if a friend comes to you and is like, man, I suck. I’ve been working really hard and Friday rolled around and we went out. I had two glasses of wine. I’m such a failure. Are you going to say to your friend, yeah, you suck. You’re a loser. You’re never going to be successful. I mean, we laugh at that because of course we would never speak that way to our friends, but we say to ourselves all of the time.
(05:59):
So shifting that a little bit, talk to ourself like we would talk to a friend, yeah, that stinks. You made a couple of bad choices, but was it because you restricted all week or you had a really tough day and you sought that glass of wine was going to make you feel better? Now we can identify, okay, tomorrow I’m going to drink a lot of extra water and make sure that I get right back on track and hit my macros and get my workout in and feel really good and honor my body with some good movement. So instead of beating ourself up for what we intend to do, which can then lead to more setbacks, we get stuck. If Friday night rolls around and we kind of blow it, how many of us have heard that? Well, I already ruined it. Might as well just wait till Monday to use one of a ryms.
(06:51):
We don’t need to slash all four of our tires, we can simply get right back on instead of keeping ourselves stuck in that all or nothing black and white thinking. Because when we look at ourselves that way, we just stay stuck. We always do those same things that we’ve been doing over and over again. Diet starts on Monday, starts let get all the unhealthy food out of the house and then I’m going to be so perfect. We tend to overcorrect even and go into that other extreme, which of course doesn’t lead to real success. It might lead to some short-term changes, but eventually we fall back into those old habits and patterns because it’s not sustainable to be so stink and mean to ourselves and to treat ourselves so unkindly.
Cori (07:38):
It also creates a lot of the mindsets which only hold us back from moving forward or implementing tools or techniques later. Because if you think about that pattern, maybe you did track all week, you hit specific macros all week, you hit specific calories all week and you cut out all the foods you love. So you then think, oh, well, I fell off on Friday because this is miserable and tracking stinks and I’ll never do tracking again. But it wasn’t the tracking. It maybe wasn’t even the macros or the calories you had. Maybe it was something that you need to adjust, but it was the fact that you chose to cut out all the foods you loved that then made things backfire or not owning the stress of making these changes to make smaller changes to meet yourself where you’re at. So in the end, because this feeling occurs, we then associate the feeling with the tool and we can’t go back to the tool.
(08:23):
So the stress, the guilt, all these different things, if we don’t really assess them, almost make it harder and harder to make the changes. Not to mention you pointed out something so important, we get that all or nothing mindset. It’s either I do the ideal or I don’t. Well, what is ideal? Ideal is something that you can actually do today to be successful with ideal is picking yourself up. When you fall down, you’re not just going to be laying on the ground in the middle of the sidewalk, whereas people step over you, you’re going to get up, stand up. Yet that’s how we sort of treat mishaps with our workout routine. We’re just laying on the sidewalk, letting people step on us.
Allison (09:01):
Yeah, I love that analogy and it makes me laugh because when we really think about that, it’s so silly. I mean, we have so many ways that we can still be successful without having to go to that other extreme of standing up and running down the sidewalk or whatever, to just take that metaphor a little farther. So really when we think about how we are going to, what is self-compassion even and how do I do this? So I think there’s three big components to self-compassion that really help frame that we are all in this together. And I love this because every single one of us, regardless of how much we present to the world as the perfect or the ideal, we all struggle. We all look in the mirror some days and don’t love the way we look or we say something and we’re just like, oh my God, I cannot believe I said that.
(09:59):
We all have that experience. So when we’re able to look at those setbacks and struggles as part of this larger common humanity that we all struggle, then it makes our challenges less unique. And that’s important because when we think that we’re the only person who’s struggling with something, it makes us feel like we’re an outsider. So if we go back to what I talked about at the start of this conversation, that’s going to be a stressful situation for our brain. Oh my God, I’m not part of the ingroup. So when we’re able to look at this from this common humanities standpoint, we’re not defective. We’re not unique in our failures. We’re just like everybody else. But that means that we can acknowledge those that suffering in a way that’s like, okay, well I had a bad day today, but I bet you that my coach had a bad day last week or whatever. So we’re able to really move past that. This is just sucky for me, and I’m the only person who’s ever had to struggle with any of this
Cori (11:02):
And not only move past a little of the self pity, which I’ve thrown plenty of pity parties myself, but in that we see that by being able to see the flaw in something, that means that we’ve already grown. And I bring that up because I’ve been putting out videos for a very long time and made lots of amazing mistakes in that time. But I’ll look back at previous blog posts I’ve written or videos I’ve done and be like, oh my goodness, I put that out that’s really out there in the world. And now I used to get all cringey and be like, should I take it down? And now I’m like, the reason I think that’s so bad is because I’ve gotten better. When we can even pause to reflect and be like, oh, that’s not how I like that situation to go. I wish I hadn’t had those glasses of wine on a Friday night.
(11:46):
That right there is that that you already need to feel proud of because that means that you’ve already grown from it. Recognizing your flaws and being able to say, okay, this is a learning experience is what moves us forward. And I bring this up because I have a hard time saying that word. It feels a little too huggy for me, but finding a way to embrace that, we need to have that. And you can’t just always beat yourself up because that internal language, like what you repeat consistently, you become right. Your actions are going to be in line with the verbiage you’re using with yourself. It’s so important. So for a non hugger, let’s go into a little bit more self-compassion and how we can really build this.
Allison (12:26):
Yes, it was so funny because actually one of the best ways to help yourself feel safe is to give yourself a hug. But you don’t have to do that, Corey. Yeah, you’re so right when you talk about being able to look at those setbacks, because we’ve grown, we’ve learned better, we know better. And now we can look at that as not a failure. I’m not a failure, I’m not doomed. This situation came up and now we can look at it as part of that longer journey. So did I track every single macro and hit everything perfectly? No, but did I track something that’s a win that’s different than maybe the way I used to behave in the past? If I don’t track it, it didn’t happen. Spoiler alert, it does. So being able to respond instead of react is really key as part of this whole idea of being self-compassionate.
(13:26):
And so again, it allows us to take a step back, and some of this may feel a little woo woo or a little huggy, but if you think about all of the years that you have spent doing the same thing of complaining, yelling at yourself, speaking really unkindly and it hasn’t worked, or maybe it’s worked in the short term but not long term, or it doesn’t leave you feeling very well, so let’s try something different. Let’s try looking at a situation almost as an outside observer. So one of the tricks that you can use is you can even just start to be a little more aware of when those thoughts pop up. This seems kind of silly, but you can even give that little inner voice a name, maybe you call it, I don’t know, Sandy, whatever, somebody you don’t like. And it helps you to create that distance, and then you can hear those thoughts and be like, oh yeah, that’s Sandy.
(14:28):
She just wants to make me feel bad about myself again, by being aware of when those thoughts come up and just sort of acknowledging them, even if you don’t have the time to sit down and journal or reflect about it, it just helps to bring that awareness more so to the forefront so that eventually you’re able to, okay, now I know when these thoughts come up every Friday night or every morning when I hit the snooze, instead of getting out of bed and going to the gym, now I have that situation a little bit more in focus and I can think about, okay, if I know that I hit snooze every morning, instead of going the gym, do I need to reevaluate when I work out? Maybe that first thing in the morning workout isn’t the best or ideal for me, or maybe I need to prep a little bit more ahead of time, have a better nighttime routine so that I’m going to bed earlier. So now we have that opportunity to identify those patterns and then wear those tweaks that we can make to improve for next time.
Cori (15:31):
It’s so key that separation between your thoughts and the actions that have to occur. And when you do name something or call it a bad roommate in your head or whatever works for you, you do create just that little bit of pause and distance to be like, okay, this is a thought I’m having, not something I have to become. And off of that too, those thoughts are going to happen. They’re going to pop up. And it’s not that we can always control them from occurring because it’s not only a routine and habit we’ve created for a very long time that we’re trying to break, but we’re human. And on top of that, we can recognize when they’re occurring to even then put in some of the positive as well, which for me, I’m not a hugger, but I do do my own form of I guess a physical fist bump.
(16:15):
And not for self-compassion, no hugging, but the bicep kiss. It’s kind of a little more awkward, but it helps. It keeps me true to what I want. But even thinking about if the negative thoughts are occurring, how can you state a positive too? Think about how many times you’ve had a brag that you then don’t say, but how willing you are to say the negative. We need to shift that mindset and realize that bragging is not being humble. It’s owning something awesome that you did and balancing out all the negative thoughts that you’ve had no problem saying.
Allison (16:47):
Yeah, I think that goes back to that whole concept of that all or nothing mindset, that if we’re not totally perfect or we haven’t quite reached that goal yet, that it’s not worth celebrating. And that’s where a lot of us end up just stuck and feeling like we’re never making any progress. But when you’re able to identify all of those places along your journey that you have gotten better, maybe you can’t do a full pull up yet, but maybe you’re doing more weight on a lap pull down, that’s growth, that’s progress towards that goal. And you can reframe instead of saying, man, I’m such a lazy person, now we’re able to say, yeah, well, you know what? I made this choice and I’m going to own it. And I know that even though I didn’t get my formal workout in, I’m going to be really intentional today with making sure that I get some extra movement in because it feels good for my body and reminding ourselves that that progress is not linear.
(17:46):
And I think that that’s the other thing that we expect to see this beautiful flat trajectory heading upward, and that’s just not reality at all. We have those ups and those downs. The difference is that when we’re in those downs or those plateaus or whatever, that we look at it and can assess, can assess where have I already been successful? What were some ways that I did improve? And yes, acknowledging that we haven’t quite gotten to that ultimate goal yet, but we’re a heck of a lot closer than we would be if we never started or if we quit when we got to one of those down days.
Cori (18:28):
And I love that you use yet because I think that word is so powerful in setting our expectations in line with what we need to do, and also not limiting ourselves with the idea that we can’t, right? It adds that little shift. I can’t do X yet. It allows for growth. But off of that too, I think it can be really hard to find the line, right? Something that’s also a strength is also a weakness. Having that negativity can be a strength and that you critique things, you analyze things you want to learn from them, but then it steers into a little bit too harsh and inner critic. How can we find that balance and realize that self-compassion doesn’t mean letting yourself off the hook, but again, that even can sometimes be overcorrected the other way.
Allison (19:13):
Yeah. So if you think about when you make an excuse for something like, oh, sorry, I was late traffic. Was it traffic? Or did you just make the choice not to leave? Soon enough? When we make excuses, we’re just dismissing the issue or we’re ignoring it. Well, this is too hard, but we’re not actually able to then move forward. We get stuck. But when we come at something with more of that, so we acknowledge like, yep, I didn’t get that workout in. I’m going to be intentional with movements later on today. And it also encourages more of that learning again, which is how we’re going to grow. So when we make excuses, we’re kind of justifying or rationalizing the behavior. Well, I was really hungry. Dieting is hard, and so I ate the pizza. But there’s no reflection there. Self-compassion means we kind of look at that behavior with more of that curiosity, why did I choose to eat pizza?
(20:21):
Maybe it was because pizza’s fricking delicious and you wanted it, right? Okay, so how can we adjust and is there a way that maybe we could have a slice of pizza with a side salad or maybe we have more of that. I dunno, veggie pizza, I guess some people like that, not me, but give me the real thing or nothing. Anyway. Also, when we’re able to that self-compassion, we can really actually improve our motivation rather than deplete it, because when we are kind to ourself, we feel better. We actually want to continue to feel that way. So think about when you’re rocking things with, whether it’s your health and fitness journey, or simply just in the zone at work, you’re feeling really good. You want to keep that good feeling going, and that’s going to help drive some of that intrinsic motivation to continue to make those choices that are going to help you feel better, that are going to lead you to those goals. But if we don’t actually give ourselves that opportunity to reflect on it, all we do is then say like, well, I’m a loser. I stink. And then we kind of just avoid or never actually get started.
Cori (21:39):
We stop the success snowball, we’ll call it, where the more you do, the more you do and the more successful you feel with things, the more you want to do those things that are making you feel really good. Versus when you do something that you can’t achieve, you set your expectations too high, you focus too much on an ideal over just what you can control, you end up doing a lot less because you’re not in that success mindset. And I love the way you frame that because I think it goes back to agency. A lot of times we give away our own agency, we say, oh, well, in critiquing ourselves, oh, well, I’m just flawed. I’m just this. I’m just that. Or even with letting ourselves off the hook, we say, I deserve this. Right? We’re not looking at our own control and our own choice in the matter. And I think the more we bring it back to, I have to take agency and ownership of this, the more we’re not letting ourselves off the hook when we do show ourselves compassion and grace, but we’re also not letting that critique become something that we’re just sort of writing off as an inherent flaw, so to speak.
Allison (22:40):
Yeah, we’re taking that power back. We actually then can take action instead of looking at all of these things that’s happening to me that’s causing all of these reasons to fail. It’s what is my role here and how can I improve? How can I take some action to move myself forward? And that’s such an empowering thing because instead of just waiting for things to happen to you, you get to choose. You get to decide. I’m like, you can hear my passion because it’s so exciting. You have this choice there. And I think that that’s a huge component. That is part of being a little bit more kind and compassionate to yourself.
Cori (23:22):
We like taking action because action feels good. It makes you feel like you’re doing something towards your goal. And while we do have to pause and think about it, and I know that has to come in into play at points, action is really what drives us forward. And so on that note, what actions can we take today, this week, this next month, to really start to build that self-compassion and be aware of that inner critic when it is trying to speak up a little too loudly?
Allison (23:47):
Yeah. So first awareness, simply noticing when you’re hearing that voice again, maybe it’s just that maybe you do a tick mark on a little sticky note or something like that and you can kind of identify, man, I’m really kind of mean to myself that awareness is important. So that’s the first step is just really being intentional about paying attention to when you hear that inner critic start to talk to you, and then when you have a little more data, a little more distance from it. So a couple of weeks, I would really give yourself that time to pay attention and be mindful of that voice. Then you can start to identify some of those patterns like I was talking about. Are there certain times of the day or certain moments that you hear that inner critic more? And then you can ask yourself, is this something I would say to a friend who is struggling and truly think about what’s the tone of voice?
(24:52):
What are the words that I’m saying to myself? And then you can say, okay, I clearly would not speak this way to a friend, friend. Now we can reframe some of that. Once you’ve got that verbiage down, now you can actually start practicing it. So when you do hear that inner critic saying, when you step on the scale and it’s like the weight’s up, I’m a failure at this, you can hear yourself and you can interrupt that pattern and say, the scale’s not reflecting the number I wanted to see, but it does not define my progress. And it’s only one piece of data in my journey. And when we are able to look at some of those setbacks or those times where we feel our inner critic yelling at us, we can then get curious about the data. What can we learn from it? How can we improve for next time?
(25:43):
And then something that you can also do that I think is really helpful is come up with a self-compassion mantra. It can be as cheesy and as corny as you want it because you’re the only person who’s going to hear it. But that acknowledgement of, I’m a human. I’m struggling. And that’s okay. And what is possible right now? And you can obviously Google, but even thinking about what are the things that I like to hear that help me feel good and help me feel better? And that will really help you start to identify what’s a mantra that’s going to resonate with you? Because if it doesn’t feel good for you, you’re going to be like, that’s dumb. I’m not going to say that to myself. So really thinking about what do you want to hear when you’re struggling and use that as your driver to generate that mantra for yourself.
Cori (26:32):
The mantras always seemed like verbal, hugging to me. I’ll be a hundred percent honest. And then I realized how many of them I had in my own life, and I was like, maybe I am a hugger. Just kidding. No. But it doesn’t have to be something that’s even a positive affirmation, so to speak. It can just be something that makes you pause so that you’re not letting that critic be so negative that you’re seeing the growth opportunity. For me, that’s just the question of why when I really have something happen or I start to criticize myself up and go, why am I critiquing this? Why am I going down this path? Why do I have these feelings? And when I start to do that, instantly I let some of the stress go and I let the emotion go because it becomes just a reflection. And we learn so much more in the reflecting than even in the doing. And the more we embrace that, the more we can grow. So I even feel proud of myself. I’m like, yeah, I’m asking myself why, and I’m pausing in this moment, and that really moves me forward. So just remember, it can be a question even that helps you stop the negativity to reflect on what you can grow from. It doesn’t have to be a verbal hug, so to speak.
Allison (27:38):
Yes. I love that.
Cori (27:40):
So on that note, Alison, any closing thoughts for somebody who’s really struggling with that negativity mindset? Who’s struggling with that? Inner critics often leading to emotional sabotage when they do really feel like they’ve just started to get that momentum going? Any closing thoughts to help them do one thing today?
Allison (27:58):
Yeah, I mean, I think just that reminder that we’re all part of this common humanity and we all have those moments of struggle. And so it’s okay. It’s okay to feel that way and just give yourself even just five minutes to say, okay, yeah, I am struggling right now. This is really hard. I want to improve. I want to do better. Something along those lines. And then really just give yourself that permission to take one action that’s going to help you move forward. And it does not have to be anything crazy. It can be something so little as simply having one more glass of water or going to bed 10 minutes early, something so stupid simple that you can do it and it’s going to just help build that momentum and that snowball effect that you’re talking about.
Cori (28:52):
And I love that you mentioned we’re not alone, even don’t hesitate to reach out in the Facebook group in the forum. Reach out for a little bit of help and motivation and to even see how other people have conquered the challenge. While it’s hard to be vulnerable in that way, not only can we potentially put some positivity out there and brag about something we’ve accomplished as we ask for that help, but we’ll see we’re not alone and we’ll come up with a lot of extra tools that might really resonate with us. Be us verbal hugger or not. Allison, thank you so much for joining me today. This was fabulous. I’d love to hear how you guys are all going to start using these tools and techniques to show yourself a little bit more of self-compassion this week.
*Note: This transcript is autogenerated there may be some unintended errors.